Is any (black) smoke good smoke?
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 8:04 pm
My understanding of diesel smoke is:
- black = too rich, partially-burned fuel
- white = no combustion; starting problems or stuttering/too lean
- blue = engine oil
So my 6 year old was watching me fiddle under the dash while the engine was running. He asks: "Daddy? Can I Rrrummm the engine?". I think - she's in park, handbrake on, no problemo. "OK," say I, "Give it a little nudge on the gas pedal".
Naturally, he smiles with joy and proceeds to lunge with maximum effort onto the gas pedal with both hands. After a brief rev up to around 3900 rpms, followed by a quick explanation to him of the term "little nudge", I notice that the revving has produced a noticeable amount of black smoke.
The vehicle was fully warmed up, but I have just recently blanked off my EGR valve, so I'm wondering if my mixture is now too rich. My fuel economy is OK, but I notice that whenever I pull away hard from a stop, other drivers are loathe to follow too closely.
My question is: can revving the engine in Neutral/Park be used as a way to calibrate the fuel pump? i.e., if she's fully warmed up, give 'er the boot, and each time she smokes a bit, dial it back a smidge until it blows just the faintest hint of black.
Or is this something that needs to be done under load (with a rear-facing back-seat passenger watching for smoke).
Anybody with seat-of-the-pants diesel tuning experience out there? I have heard rumours of the evils of running too lean... Thanks,
Tony.
- black = too rich, partially-burned fuel
- white = no combustion; starting problems or stuttering/too lean
- blue = engine oil
So my 6 year old was watching me fiddle under the dash while the engine was running. He asks: "Daddy? Can I Rrrummm the engine?". I think - she's in park, handbrake on, no problemo. "OK," say I, "Give it a little nudge on the gas pedal".
Naturally, he smiles with joy and proceeds to lunge with maximum effort onto the gas pedal with both hands. After a brief rev up to around 3900 rpms, followed by a quick explanation to him of the term "little nudge", I notice that the revving has produced a noticeable amount of black smoke.
The vehicle was fully warmed up, but I have just recently blanked off my EGR valve, so I'm wondering if my mixture is now too rich. My fuel economy is OK, but I notice that whenever I pull away hard from a stop, other drivers are loathe to follow too closely.
My question is: can revving the engine in Neutral/Park be used as a way to calibrate the fuel pump? i.e., if she's fully warmed up, give 'er the boot, and each time she smokes a bit, dial it back a smidge until it blows just the faintest hint of black.
Or is this something that needs to be done under load (with a rear-facing back-seat passenger watching for smoke).
Anybody with seat-of-the-pants diesel tuning experience out there? I have heard rumours of the evils of running too lean... Thanks,
Tony.